Jew / Not Jew
The Question

Is Jay Sherman Jewish?


Jay Sherman portrait
Short Answer

Jay Sherman sits on the borderline.

Verdict: Borderline Jew · 10/15


Allow us to be serious for a moment. We're going to talk about adoption. And we're going to use a character from an obscure animated series to do so. Jay Sherman was "The Critic". Jay Sherman looked, talked, and acted Jewish. Jay Sherman was played by Jewish actor Jon Lovitz. But Jay Sherman was adopted as a baby. By…

Identity
2/5
Observance
5/5
Klout
3/5