Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №222f20

Adolf Merkl

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

If you spend any time studying Austrian legal history—and really, who doesn't on a Friday night?—you will immediately bump into Hans Kelsen. Kelsen, born to Jewish parents in Prague, essentially built modern constitutional review and drafted the 1920 Austrian Federal Constitution. But right by his side was Adolf Julius Merkl, a brilliant legal theorist who helped devise the Stufenbaulehre, or the "hierarchy of legal norms."

Naturally, in 20th-century Central European academia, when a distinguished thinker hangs around Jewish intellectuals, writes for liberal social-democratic causes, and spends his career dismantling authoritarian legal nonsense, people start wondering about his pedigree. Add to that the fact that after the 1938 Anschluss, Merkl ran into political friction with the Nazis and was shipped off to Tübingen rather than given the keys to Vienna, and casual observers might assume he was part of the tribe.

He wasn't. Merkl was born into a thoroughly Catholic, Gentile Austrian civil service family. His friction with the Third Reich wasn't over his bloodline—it was merely because he believed in quaint, old-fashioned concepts like the rule of law and constitutional democracy, which were rather unpopular in Germany at the time.

So while Kelsen provided the Jewish genius behind Austria's foundational legal architecture, Merkl was just the devoted, hyper-competent, very Gentile colleague who helped make it all work. An admirable jurist with an unfortunately common Austrian first name, but not one of ours.

Filed November 15, 2026 · historical-figures

See Also