Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Ana da Silva
NotaJew
Profile №90e58a

Ana da Silva

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
3
K
0 / 15

If you were an angsty teenager in late-1970s London, you had punk. If you were slightly weirder, more artistic, and preferred off-kilter violin scratches to generic three-chord bluster, you had The Raincoats. Co-founded by Ana da Silva and Gina Birch, the band essentially pioneered DIY post-punk, releasing a seminal debut album that Kurt Cobain famously championed so hard he practically wore through the vinyl.

Da Silva wasn't a Londoner by birth; she grew up in Madeira, Portugal, under the repressive Salazar regime, studying philology before escaping to London after the Carnation Revolution. There she discovered art school, cheap electric guitars, and the sudden revelation that you didn't need to know how to play an instrument properly to create magnificent, jagged post-punk masterpieces.

So what about the Jewish angle? Well, Portugal certainly has its deep history of conversos and Sephardic ancestry, and "da Silva" is a quintessential Portuguese surname borne by many descendants of forcibly converted Jews centuries ago. But that is ancient genealogy, not identity. Da Silva was raised Catholic in Portugal, has never identified as Jewish, and her cultural roots are pure Iberian rebel.

Kurt Cobain may have worshipped her, Sonic Youth may have adored her, and anyone with decent taste in indie rock owes her a debt of gratitude. But when it comes to the tribe, she belongs strictly to the pantheon of indie rock gods, not the Chosen People.

Filed November 9, 2026 · musicians-and-singers

See Also