Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Arthur Garfield Hays
Jew
Profile №531eaa

Arthur Garfield Hays

Verdict: Jew
I · O · K Score
3
I
5
O
4
K
0 / 15

Arthur Garfield Hays was named after James A. Garfield, because nothing says "assimilated American Jewish family in the 1880s" quite like slapping the name of a recently assassinated Republican president on your newborn son. Born into a prosperous German-Jewish household in Rochester, New York, Hays grew up with all the cultural trappings of German-American Judaism and none of the intense religious piety. He preferred the courtroom to the synagogue, finding his true calling defending the First Amendment with the zeal of a biblical prophet—just with much better legal precedent.

As the longtime general counsel for the ACLU, Hays ended up in the middle of almost every blockbuster civil liberties brawl of the early 20th century. He was co-counsel alongside Clarence Darrow in the Scopes Monkey Trial (fighting for evolution), went to bat for Sacco and Vanzetti (fighting for due process), defended Henry Sweet in Detroit (fighting racial segregation), and even traveled to Nazi Germany to observe the Reichstag fire trial, because apparently he hadn't yet irritated enough authoritarians.

Hays famously championed free speech to its absolute, uncomfortable limits, regularly defending the rights of communists, fascists, and everyone in between to speak their minds. While he wasn't particularly observant—his religion was pretty much the Bill of Rights—he never hid his heritage and frequently tackled antisemitism, both at home and abroad. A fierce, unapologetic civil libertarian whose middle name was an accident of American history, but whose legacy was pure kvell-inducing lawyering.

Filed November 10, 2026 · historical-figures

See Also