Astor Piazzolla
Tango is not generally known as the soundtrack to the bar mitzvah circuit, but if anyone could have smuggled a klezmer clarinet into a dark Buenos Aires milonga, it would have been Astor Piazzolla. The man basically grabbed traditional Argentine tango by its lapels, shook out the dust, and injected it with jazz harmonies, Bach-like counterpoint, and classical dissonance to invent nuevo tango. Traditionalists hated him so much they literally threatened his life, which, let's be honest, sounds like the exact reaction Jewish reformers get from the Orthodox.
Adding to the confusion, Piazzolla spent his formative childhood years running around Greenwich Village and the Lower East Side of Manhattan in the 1920s and 30s. He spoke fluent English, hung out with immigrant kids, learned to fight on the streets, and grew up swimming in a melting pot dense with Jewish culture. He even picked up musical tricks from a diverse array of New York neighbors before heading back south to conquer the bandoneon.
Alas, cultural osmosis does not a minyan make. Piazzolla was born to Italian immigrant parents—his father Vicente hailed from Trani, Puglia, and his mother Asunta descended from Lucca, Tuscany. He was raised Catholic, lived Catholic, and composed some of the most heart-wrenchingly dramatic music on Earth without a drop of Jewish blood.
So while his melancholic, minor-key masterpieces like Adiós Nonino sound like they could accompany a dramatic reading of the Book of Lamentations, Astor remains strictly an Italian-Argentine maestro. We will have to look elsewhere for our tango nachas.


