Beniamino Gigli
If you were an Italian opera aficionado in the 1920s mourning the untimely demise of Enrico Caruso, you didn't have to despair for long. Enter Beniamino Gigli, the shoemaker's son from Recanati whose velvety, lyrical tenor became so beloved he was christened "Caruso Secondo." For decades, audiences wept, swooned, and pelted the stage with flowers as Gigli unleashed his trademark sob on the world's most gilded opera stages.
Given the name "Beniamino," the hopeful onomastic detective might wonder if there's a biblical, Tribe of Benjamin connection waiting to be unearthed. Alas, no. In Italy, Beniamino is just an old-fashioned Catholic given name, occasionally bestowed upon the youngest child. Gigli’s parents, Domenico and Ester, were devout Roman Catholics through and through, and young Beniamino got his musical start singing in the cathedral choir, not prepping a bar mitzvah haftarah.
Then came the messy political overture. Unlike Arturo Toscanini, who told Benito Mussolini where to shove his fascist anthems, Gigli famously became Il Duce's favorite singer, happily serenading the regime and even performing for Adolf Hitler in Germany. After the war, Gigli defended himself as merely an apolitical artist who just wanted to sing for everyone—a classic, tone-deaf aria that briefly alienated him from the post-war public before his golden throat charmed everyone into forgiving him.
So, while Gigli left behind hundreds of recordings and a reputation as one of the sweetest voices in classical music history, none of that nachas belongs to us. He was about as Jewish as a plate of prosciutto wrapped around a sausage, singing Ave Maria on the steps of the Vatican.


