Bill Evans
Look at a picture of Bill Evans in the late 1950s: hunched over the keyboard, wearing thick horn-rimmed glasses, looking like an assistant professor of Talmud who wandered into a smoky Greenwich Village nightclub by mistake. Add in the fact that he was an introspective, neurotic master of modal harmony who basically revolutionized modern jazz piano, and you can understand why half of Manhattan assumed he was an alumnus of a Bronx yeshiva.
Alas, appearances can deceive, especially in jazz. William John Evans was born in New Jersey to a father of Welsh descent who ran a golf course and a mother of Russian background. But that Russian side wasn't fleeing Cossacks in the Pale of Settlement; they were devout Eastern Orthodox Christians. In fact, young Bill spent his Sundays singing in the choir of a Russian Orthodox church, not preparing for a bar mitzvah.
So while Evans played with plenty of Jews, influenced generations of Jewish pianists, and possessed the melancholic, world-weary disposition traditionally associated with our finest intellectuals, the man himself didn't have a drop of Jewish heritage. You can still kvell over "Waltz for Debby" and his historic work on Miles Davis's "Kind of Blue," but you'll have to do so knowing that the jazz world's most brooding, scholarly pianist belongs strictly in the Goy column.


