Cleon Jones
If you are an aficionado of the 1969 Miracle Mets, Cleon Jones is practically a holy figure. An Alabama native with a buttery-smooth swing, Jones hit .340 that year, made the All-Star team, and famously caught the final out of the World Series in left field before sinking to one knee in grateful prayer. In Queens, that prayer was answered, and a generation of long-suffering New York fans attained baseball nirvana.
Then there is the Shoe Polish Incident. In Game 5 of that same Fall Classic, a pitch allegedly grazed Jones's foot. Umpire Lou DiMuro initially called it a ball, until Mets manager Gil Hodges marched out with the ball, pointing out a smudge of black shoe polish. DiMuro changed the call, Jones was awarded first base, and Donn Clendenon followed with a game-tying two-run homer. It remains one of the craftiest moments in baseball history, though Hodges was Catholic and Jones was, well, Baptist.
So why check on Cleon? Aside from playing in the most heavily Jewish baseball market on earth, there's always that outside hope when looking through 1960s box scores that someone with a slightly atypical first name might surprise us. Alas, Cleon is not short for Chaim, and Jones has spent his post-baseball life doing admirable community work restoring homes in his hometown of Africatown, Alabama—decidedly outside the shtetl.
A legendary Met, an indelible part of New York sports lore, and a beloved figure to thousands of Jewish fans who lost their minds at Shea Stadium in the autumn of '69. But Jewish himself? Not even a speck.




