Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Connie Mack
NotaJew
Profile №2201f8

Connie Mack

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

If you glance at old black-and-white photos of Connie Mack, you might think you're looking at a severe East Coast rabbi who somehow wandered onto a baseball diamond. Tall, thin, and strictly dressed in a sharp three-piece business suit and bowler hat—he famously refused to wear a baseball uniform while managing—Mack looked like he should be auditing a synagogue's ledger rather than calling for a squeeze play.

Alas, looks can be deceiving. The man born Cornelius McGillicuddy was about as Irish and Catholic as a corned beef brisket boiled in holy water. His parents, Michael McGillicuddy and Mary McKillop, were Irish immigrants who fled the Potato Famine and settled in Massachusetts. Mack remained a devout, practicing Roman Catholic his entire life, even if his 50-year reign as manager of the Philadelphia Athletics felt like an endurance test only Moses could truly appreciate.

And what a reign it was. Mack holds Major League Baseball records that will literally never be broken: most managerial wins (3,731) and most managerial losses (3,948), thanks to managing until he was 87 years old and owning the team so nobody could fire him. He won five World Series championships, built legendary dynasties, and then periodically traded away all his star players whenever he went broke. Shrewd? Sure. Jewish? Not even a little.

So while Connie Mack represents the pinnacle of early baseball history, and gave us generations of athletic lore, he offers zero nachas for our team. Stick to Hank Greenberg and Sandy Koufax; the grand old man of baseball belongs strictly to St. Patrick.

Filed November 15, 2026 · athletes-and-coaches

See Also