Dennis Hoey
If you grew up watching the Basil Rathbone and Nigel Bruce Sherlock Holmes films of the 1940s, you know Inspector Lestrade not as Conan Doyle’s cunning, tenacious Scotland Yard bulldog, but as a bumbling, easily flustered buffoon whose main job was to stand around looking confounded while Holmes picked up cigarette ash. The man who brought that delightful level of incompetence to life was English character actor Dennis Hoey.
Hoey, born Samuel David Hyams in London in 1893, did not start out as a blustery cinematic cop. He began his career singing opera and performing Shakespearean theater across the UK, eventually hopping the pond to play everything from Victorian gentleman to assorted movie thugs. With a birth name like Samuel David Hyams, your Jewish radar might be pinging so loud it wakes the neighbors. His parents were indeed British-born with Russian/Dutch Jewish roots, running an inn in Brighton.
Yet young Samuel saw fit to leave his birth name behind, rechristening himself Dennis Hoey—a name that sounds like it should be working the docks in County Cork rather than celebrating Yom Kippur in Whitechapel. While he spent the rest of his life and career firmly detached from the synagogue, one can hardly fault an early 20th-century actor for trading an obviously Jewish moniker for something studio heads could digest without choking on their cigars.
So while Lestrade could never figure out how the jewels went missing from the locked room, we have managed to solve the mystery of Dennis Hoey: definitely born into the tribe, even if he spent his acting prime pretending to be the quintessential thick-headed British bobby.




