Don McLean
For decades, listeners parsing the cryptic, eight-and-a-half-minute pop-cultural eulogy that is "American Pie" have wondered about the man behind the Chevy and the levee. Between the dark, poetic introspection, the Greenwich Village folk-scene pedigree, and a surname that casual ears occasionally conflate with something vaguely Semitic, plenty of folks just assumed Don McLean was one of ours. Add in that Roberta Flack's "Killing Me Softly with His Song" was inspired by watching McLean perform, and you've got enough soulful angst to convince half of Long Island that he must be a landsman.
Alas, a long, long time ago, McLean was born into a staunchly Catholic household in New Rochelle, New York. His ancestry traces back to Scotland on his father's side and Catholic Italy on his mother's (her maiden name was Buccacci). He attended Iona Preparatory School, an all-boys Catholic school, and was raised firmly in the Church. There are no secret bar mitzvahs, no hidden grandmothers from Vilna, and not a shred of Jewish lineage hiding under that Chevy's hood.
So while he gave us an immortal, generational anthem and wrote "Vincent" (a tribute to a tortured, earless Dutch painter who was also not Jewish), Don McLean belongs entirely to the gentiles. We'll always have Bob Dylan to fill the cryptic-poet quota, but McLean remains definitively, unequivocally goyishe.


