Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Jew
Profile №a703b8

Erskine Mayer

Verdict: Jew
I · O · K Score
4
I
5
O
3
K
0 / 15

Before Sandy Koufax made skipping World Series games for Yom Kippur legendary, there was Erskine Mayer. Born in Atlanta in 1889 to a German-Jewish family, Mayer spent his prime pitching for the Philadelphia Phillies in the deadball era, relying on a devastating spitball back when lathering up a baseball with whatever bodily fluids you could muster was not only legal, but encouraged. He won 21 games in both 1914 and 1915, forming a formidable one-two punch alongside Hall of Famer Grover Cleveland Alexander.

In the 1915 World Series against the Boston Red Sox, Mayer took the mound for Game 2, matching up against a young fellow named Babe Ruth—well, technically Ruth was on the bench, but you get the era. Mayer pitched brilliantly, giving up only one earned run, but still took the loss. A few years later, he was traded to the Chicago White Sox just in time for the infamous 1919 "Black Sox" World Series. Luckily for Erskine, he pitched one inning of relief, gave up nothing, and avoided the lifetime bans handed down to his crooked teammates. Being clean on that squad was practically a miracle.

Mayer was openly and proudly Jewish throughout his career, often having to contend with the garden-variety bench jockeying of the 1910s. Along with his brother Sam, who also briefly played in the majors, Erskine was one of the earliest prominent Jewish ballplayers in an era when Jewish mothers would rather their sons become anything other than professional athletes. Retiring with 91 career wins and a squeaky-clean reputation, he's a certified pioneer of the Tribe on the diamond.

Filed November 21, 2026 · athletes-and-coaches

See Also