Eugenio Montale
If you flip through an anthology of 20th-century Italian poetry, you might easily get the impression that Eugenio Montale belongs in the tribe. After all, his great literary muse, immortalized as "Clizia" in his verse, was the Jewish-American Dante scholar Irma Brandeis. His longtime companion and eventual wife, Drusilla Tanzi, was Jewish and a niece of Italo Svevo (himself born Ettore Schmitz). And when Mussolini and the Nazis turned Florence into a hunting ground, Montale put his neck on the line by hiding Jewish writers like Umberto Saba and Carlo Levi in his apartment.
Add to that his Nobel Prize in Literature in 1975, his translations of T.S. Eliot and James Joyce, and his uncompromising refusal to join the Fascist Party—which cost him his job as director of the prestigious Gabinetto Vieusseux library—and you have someone who was, by all accounts, an honorary member of the club in every way that mattered.
Except, well, genealogically. Montale was born into a staunchly bourgeois, Catholic merchant family in Genoa to parents Domenico Montale and Giuseppina Ricci. He was baptized, raised Catholic, and possessed precisely zero drops of Jewish lineage.
So while we are more than happy to kvell over a poet who wrote hermetic masterpieces and hid our people from the Gestapo, we can't claim him on the census. An anti-fascist hero and a literary giant, yes; a Member of the Tribe, no.



