Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
BorderlineJew
Profile №dbccea

Felix Mendelssohn

Verdict: Borderline Jew
I · O · K Score
1
I
5
O
4
K
0 / 15

Being the grandson of Moses Mendelssohn—the great philosopher of the Jewish Enlightenment who practically invented modern Jewish intellectualism—is quite the pedigree. Unfortunately, Felix’s father, Abraham, looked at 19th-century Europe and decided that talent and genius were great, but baptism was much better for a career. Thus, young Felix was baptized into the Reformed Christian Church at age seven and saddled with the Christian hyphenate "Bartholdy" to smooth over any lingering hints of the ghetto.

Felix took his Lutheranism seriously, composing magnificent Christian oratorios like Elijah and St. Paul, and reviving the long-forgotten sacred music of J.S. Bach. Yet for all his churchgoing and hyphenating, German society never quite let him forget who his grandfather was. Richard Wagner, carrying on his usual hobby of unhinged antisemitism, spent an entire essay whining that Mendelssohn’s music was inherently superficial because of his Semitic blood.

So while Felix didn't practice Judaism—and actually bristled whenever people dropped the "Bartholdy" his father desperately paid for—his lineage was pure tribe. He gave the world the Hebrides Overture, the Violin Concerto in E minor, and the quintessential Wedding March, all while reminding us that in the eyes of European bigots, once a Mendelssohn, always a Mendelssohn.

Filed November 18, 2026 · musicians-and-singers

See Also