Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Jew-ish
Profile №e8fb54

Florence Eldridge

Verdict: Jew-ish
I · O · K Score
1
I
3
O
3
K
0 / 15

Florence Eldridge spent most of her career sharing the marquee with her two-time Oscar-winning husband, Fredric March. Together, they tackled Eugene O'Neill on Broadway, faced down HUAC in the Red Scare era, and played opposite each other in classics like "Inherit the Wind," where she portrayed the loyal, fretful wife of Matthew Harrison Brady (March's thinly-veiled William Jennings Bryan).

Born Florence McKechnie in Brooklyn, her surname sounds like bagpipes and shortbread, not knishes and pastrami. But looks—and married names—can be deceiving. Eldridge's mother, Clara Eugenie Baur, was Jewish, born to parents who emigrated from Bohemia and Germany. That matrilineal descent makes Eldridge halachically Jewish, even if her stage name and public persona were thoroughly WASP-coded.

Despite the Jewish roots, Eldridge wasn't lighting Shabbat candles or headlining Hadassah luncheons. She and March were quintessential mid-century liberal intellectuals, fighting blacklists and donating to civil rights causes rather than synagogal building funds.

Still, for an actress best remembered playing the dutiful wife of an evangelical fundamentalist crusader in "Inherit the Wind," finding out she was secretly one of the tribe adds a delightful layer of cosmic irony.

Filed November 21, 2026 · actresses

See Also