Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №13075e

Florence Reece

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
1
K
0 / 15

If you have ever stood on a picket line, attended a socialist summer camp, or listened to Pete Seeger aggressively strum a banjo until his fingers bled, you know "Which Side Are You On?" It is the undisputed heavyweight champion of American labor anthems, scribbled down in 1931 on a calendar torn off the wall while trigger-happy company thugs terrorized Harlan County, Kentucky.

The woman who wrote it was Florence Reece, the wife of union organizer Sam Reece. When the coal operators sent armed deputies to ransack her cabin looking for her husband, Florence protected her children, waited for the goons to leave, and turned Appalachian Baptist hymn cadences into timeless class-warfare poetry. Decades later, she was still singing it into microphones with an iron resolve that could intimidate a strike-breaker from two counties over.

Given the overwhelming overlap between mid-century American labor activism, folk song preservation, and New York Jewish radicals, a casual observer might assume Florence shared a lineage with the folks at the Workmen's Circle. Alas, no. Reece was mountain folk through and through, born Florence Patton in Tennessee, with roots deep in the Scotch-Irish Appalachian soil.

So while generations of Jewish leftists embraced her song as if it were handed down at Mount Sinai alongside a union card, Florence Reece was not one of ours. Not even a little. But if you're on the workers' side, we suspect she wouldn't mind the confusion.

Filed November 5, 2026 · musicians-and-singers

See Also