Garnet Mimms
If you flip through a roll call of mid-century soul belters and land on "Garnet Mimms," you might pause for a second. Could it be? An obscure cousin of the Mims or Mimms clans of Brooklyn? Perhaps someone who hung around the Brill Building long enough to pick up a little Yiddish alongside his chord charts? After all, Mimms made his biggest splash collaborating with legendary Jewish songwriters Jerry Ragovoy and Bert Berns on the thunderous, spine-tingling 1963 hit "Cry Baby."
Alas, no. Born Garrett Mimms in Ashland, West Virginia, and raised in Philadelphia, he cut his teeth exactly where you'd expect a golden-era soul icon to: singing gospel in church choirs. His musical pedigree includes groups like the Evening Stars and the Norfolk Four before he assembled the Enchanters. The name might have a quirky ring to it, but there isn't a drop of matzah ball soup in his lineage.
Ragovoy wrote "Cry Baby" specifically with Mimms's church-honed, emotional crescendo in mind, and Janis Joplin famously turned it into rock history a few years later. Mimms eventually stepped away from the secular spotlight in the late 1970s, returning full-time to his Christian roots to become a born-again minister and prison chaplain.
So while his greatest hit was co-crafted by members of the tribe, Garnet Mimms himself was strictly an honorary guest at the Brill Building seder. A magnificent voice, a towering influence on rock and soul, but entirely, unequivocally Goyish.


