Götz von Berlichingen
Götz von Berlichingen, a German knight active during the late 15th and early 16th centuries, earned his memorable nickname after losing his right hand in battle and replacing it with a rather impressive iron prosthetic. This technological marvel allowed him to continue his swashbuckling career, which involved a fair bit of feuding, fighting, and, occasionally, getting captured.
His adventures were so compelling that Johann Wolfgang von Goethe wrote a play about him, cementing his place in German literary history. One of his most enduring legacies, however, is a particular scatological phrase he allegedly uttered, which has become a rather robust German idiom for telling someone to go away.
Unsurprisingly, given his background as a German nobleman during the Holy Roman Empire, there is precisely zero indication that Götz von Berlichingen had any connection whatsoever to Judaism. His Jewish identity, origin, and any potential kvell-worthiness are all firmly rooted in the realm of nil. We'd be more likely to find him kvelling over a successful raid than a Bris.
His notoriety, however, is undeniable. While he might not have brought nachas to any Jewish mothers, he certainly brought enough drama to inspire one of Germany's most famous writers. A solid example of a historical figure who is emphatically, and rather humorously, not one of "ours."

