Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Heinrich Heine
BorderlineJew
Profile №b10174

Heinrich Heine

Verdict: Borderline Jew
I · O · K Score
4
I
2
O
4
K
0 / 15

If Germany has a national poet, it's Heinrich Heine, and if it has a national poem, it's "Die Lorelei". It tells of a siren that lives in the eponymous river, luring sailors with her song. So it's no surprise that some Germans wanted to honor the poem and its author by building a monument to it and him. And what better place to honor Heine than his birthplace of Dusseldorf!

Not so fast: some of the ever-tolerant Germans rejected the tribute to their supposedly-favorite son. You see, Heine was born Jewish.

German-Americans stepped in. Apparently they had no qualms with Heine's origins, so a monument was commissioned and ready to be placed, smack in the middle of Manhattan.

Not so fast: the monument was to be... not aesthetically pleasing.

A long tug-of-war ensued, and Lorelei ended up in the Bronx, where, according to an architecture magazine, its ugliness could be hidden among "the mass of wooden tenements and crazy beer-shops".

It still stands in the Bronx, in a park, a short walk from Yankee Stadium. And... yeah, it's pretty ugly, siren and all.

But at least there's a New York City monument honoring a Jew. Thanks, Germany!

Filed May 15, 2026 · writers

See Also