Henryk Erlich
History is full of bad ideas, but believing Joseph Stalin when he promises to support a democratic socialist Jewish movement ranks pretty high up there. Henryk Erlich was a heavyweight of the General Jewish Labour Bund in Poland and the Russian Empire—meaning he dedicated his life to secular Yiddishkayt, democratic socialism, and the quaint belief that Jews didn't need to flee to Palestine because they could build a worker's paradise right where they were.
Erlich was as authentically Jewish and ideologically committed as they came. He edited Yiddish socialist papers, served on the Petrograd Soviet, and fought both Tsarist crackdowns and rising Polish fascism. When the Nazis invaded Poland in 1939, he fled east, straight into the loving arms of the NKVD. After a delightful stay in Soviet prisons, Stalin suddenly realized he needed Western Jewish support against Hitler. So, Erlich and his fellow Bundist Victor Alter were pulled out of their cells, brushed off, and tasked with organizing what would become the Jewish Anti-Fascist Committee.
Naturally, once Stalin realized that independent-minded, internationally connected Jewish socialists might not be entirely docile lapdogs, the hospitality ended abruptly. In late 1941, Erlich was re-arrested, framed as a Nazi spy (because who better to work for Hitler than an outspoken Jewish socialist?), and ultimately committed suicide in a Soviet prison in 1942 to escape execution. A tragic end to a principled life, proving once again that a dictator's gratitude is the most dangerous thing a Jew can earn.

