Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Jew
Profile №5ae64d

Herbert Samuel

Verdict: Jew
I · O · K Score
4
I
5
O
4
K
0 / 15

Before Herbert Samuel came along, British politics had seen Benjamin Disraeli ascend to the very top, but Disraeli was famously baptized as a child. Thus, when Samuel joined H.H. Asquith's cabinet as Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster in 1909, he became the first nominal and practicing Jew to sit at the table without having to cross himself or pretend to love bacon. (Though "practicing" came with a rather massive asterisk, as we'll see.)

Samuel was born into the wealthy, aristocratic Anglo-Jewish cousinhood—his uncle was Samuel Montagu, 1st Baron Swaythling, an ultra-devout banker who took keeping kosher very, very seriously. Young Herbert, on the other hand, quietly abandoned his religious faith while studying at Oxford. He remained an atheist his entire adult life, yet he kept an impeccably kosher household and attended synagogue regularly out of respect for his family and community, which is perhaps the most quintessentially Jewish maneuver in the history of British politics.

His greatest historical impact, however, came during World War I and its aftermath. Samuel authored the 1915 memorandum "The Future of Palestine," pushing the British government to support a Jewish homeland long before the Balfour Declaration made it official policy. He was later appointed the first High Commissioner of the British Mandate for Palestine in 1920. Trying to be a fair-minded British civil servant while governing your ancestral homeland turned out to be an impossible task: the Arabs deeply resented him for being Jewish and Zionist, while many Zionists accused him of bending over backward to appease the Arab population.

Still, between pioneering British broadcasting, leading the Liberal Party, and navigating early Mandatory Palestine without completely losing his dignity, Samuel gave his community plenty of nachas. He proved you could reach the highest echelons of the British Empire without having to get dunked in holy water first.

Filed November 14, 2026 · politicians

See Also