Holden Caulfield
J.D. Salinger famously gave Holden Caulfield an awful lot of his own biographical DNA: an upper-crust Manhattan upbringing, prep school expulsions, a nervous breakdown, and a general disgust with the phoniness of the adult world. But Salinger stopped short of giving Holden his exact ethnic lineage. Salinger himself was half-Jewish (his father was Jewish, his mother was of Scotch-Irish descent who converted or passed). Holden, however, is firmly planted on Park Avenue with a distinctly Anglo-Saxon pedigree, though his mother was raised Catholic.
In fact, Holden explicitly mentions his parents' religious differences in "The Catcher in the Rye." His father is of Catholic background or non-practicing WASP heritage, while his mother was Catholic, but they gave up religion altogether after Holden's younger brother Allie died. Holden self-identifies as an atheist who likes Jesus just fine, but can't stand the Disciples because they were useless until after Jesus died. There is nary a mention of a bar mitzvah, a bris, or a Friday night dinner anywhere in his rambling weekend around New York.
Yet for generations of neurotic, over-analytical, alienated city kids, Holden felt spiritually Jewish. The hyper-verbal self-deprecation, the existential dread, the endless kvetching about everyone being a "phony"—it's basically Philip Roth with a red hunting hat. Salinger's Jewish sensibilities certainly bled onto the page, but that doesn't make Holden one of the tribe.
Holden may be the ultimate mascot for teenage angst and mid-century angst, but genealogically and religiously speaking, he belongs strictly to the prep-school goyim.




