Isaac Goldsmid
Sir Isaac Lyon Goldsmid was many things: a titan of the London bullion market, a relentless crusader for Jewish political emancipation, a key founder of University College London, and the very first practicing Jew to be created an English baronet by Queen Victoria. What he was not, despite whatever peculiar fever dream produced the rumor, was a pioneer of overhand bowling in Victorian cricket.
Cricket historians know that the revolution from underhand to overarm bowling belonged to folks like John Willes, William Lillywhite, and Edgar Willsher (who famously walked off the pitch at The Oval in 1862 after being no-balled). Sir Isaac, meanwhile, was far too occupied financing Portuguese and Brazilian state loans, building docks, and battling the House of Lords to spend his afternoons chucking leather spheres at wooden stumps. If he ever bowled a maiden over, it was strictly metaphorical and probably involved an arranged marriage between prominent Anglo-Jewish dynasties.
On the actual playing field of Jewish history, however, Goldsmid bowled absolute fire. At a time when Jews were barred from Parliament, Oxford, and Cambridge, he poured his immense wealth into funding non-sectarian education at UCL and spent decades lobbying until the Jewish Relief Act finally passed. He also helped break the Orthodox monopoly in Britain by co-founding the West London Synagogue of British Jews. No wickets taken, perhaps, but a hall-of-fame performance nonetheless.

