James Hutton
If you've ever looked at a rock and thought, "Gee, that rock looks older than six thousand years," you have James Hutton to thank. The 18th-century Scottish Enlightenment polymath essentially looked at the cliffs of Siccar Point, saw layers of sandstone stacked perpendicularly upon other layers of sandstone, and realized that Earth had been around for a mind-bogglingly long time. He called it "deep time," concluding that there was "no vestige of a beginning, no prospect of an end." Young Earth creationists have been grinding their teeth ever since.
Hutton wasn't just a geologist; he was a physician, chemist, and experimental farmer who hung out with Adam Smith and James Watt in Edinburgh, drinking claret and completely dismantling the literal interpretation of Genesis. His theory of plutonism argued that the subterranean heat of the Earth—not Noah's flood—formed the rocks we see today. Naturally, the pious establishment called him an atheist and a heretic, though he insisted he was just admiring the machinery of God's magnificent, endlessly recycling terrarium.
So what about his Jewish background? Well, Hutton was born in Edinburgh to a merchant father who served as City Treasurer, was baptized in the Church of Scotland, and represents about as pure a distillation of the Scottish Enlightenment as one can find outside of a peat bog. There are no secret rabbinical dynasties hidden in the Lothians, no distant Sephardic ancestors, and definitely no mezuzah on the door at Siccar Point.
Still, we have to respect a man whose life work fundamentally rested on looking at an ancient geological formation and delivering a long, exasperated, highly detailed lecture on how everyone else in the room was entirely wrong. It might not make him a member of the tribe, but the vibe is undeniable.




