James J. Braddock
If you have seen the Hollywood film starring Russell Crowe, you know the story: a washed-up, impoverished heavyweight during the Great Depression works the docks, gets a miracle shot at the title against a murderous puncher, and wins. It was an all-American fairy tale, earning James J. Braddock the forever-nickname "Cinderella Man."
The antagonist in that fairy tale, however, was Max Baer. In the movie, Baer was caricatured as a sneering, bloodthirsty brute who practically bragged about killing men in the ring. In reality, Baer was a charismatic, affable playboy who wore a Star of David on his boxing trunks to honor his Jewish heritage and defy Adolf Hitler. So when Braddock beat Baer in 1935, Hollywood framed it as good triumphing over evil, but from our perspective, it was a very Catholic Irishman pulling an upset over the fellow in the Magen David shorts.
Braddock was born in Hell's Kitchen to Irish immigrant parents, baptized Roman Catholic, and spent his life squarely within that identity. There is not a drop of Jewish heritage here, nor did he ever claim any. He was an honorable man, paid back his government relief money as soon as he won the purse, and served his country in World War II.
A great boxing story, a great American underdog, and thoroughly, impeccably Irish. If you're looking for Jewish heavyweight glory from that golden era, you'll have to stick with the guy he beat.




