Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Jim Sinegal
NotaJew
Profile №bb2039

Jim Sinegal

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

If you have ever purchased a fifty-pound drum of peanut butter, a six-pack of flannel shirts, and a surprisingly good hot dog for a grand total of fifteen dollars, you have two men to thank. One was Jeffrey Brotman, an actual Son of the Covenant who provided the initial investment and retail vision. The other was Jim Sinegal, the legendary CEO who insisted on paying employees living wages, capping profit margins, and famously threatening murder if anyone dared raise the price of the $1.50 food court hot dog combo.

With a business model centered on unbelievable bargains, obsessive penny-pinching on operations, and an unshakeable love for bulk paper towels, people inevitably jump to conclusions. Surely the retail wizard who mastered wholesale must have some Jewish blood? Plus, working in tandem with Brotman for decades gave Costco that distinct, warm warehouse-synagogue-basement aura.

Alas, no. Sinegal was born in Pittsburgh into a working-class Catholic family. He got his start bagging groceries at FedMart under another Jewish retail pioneer, Sol Price, whom Sinegal revered as a mentor. But being mentored by Sol Price and partnered with Jeff Brotman does not make you a member of the tribe by osmosis.

So while Sinegal is undeniably an mensch in the cutthroat corporate world—earning legendary respect for treating human beings with dignity—he remains entirely, unequivocally goyishe. Enjoy the hot dog, but hold the brisket.

Filed October 25, 2026 · businesspeople

See Also