Joe Meek
Wait, Joe Meek? The eccentric, tone-deaf, tape-splicing mad scientist of 304 Holloway Road? The man who gave the world the Tornados' otherworldly space-age instrumental "Telstar"? Yes, that Joe Meek. Except for one glaring detail in the pitch: Meek was not Jewish. Not even a tiny bit. He was born Robert George Meek in Gloucestershire to an ordinary English farming family—specifically George and Biddy Meek—and his primary spiritual pursuits involved séances, recording cemetery cats to capture the voices of the dead, and consulting the spirit of Buddy Holly.
Meek is indeed a legendary pioneer of modern music production, pioneering overdubbing, reverb, and compression in a tiny flat above a leather goods shop. He was certainly brilliant, deeply troubled, intensely paranoid, and famously homosexual during an era when it was criminalized in the UK. But a Jewish record producer? You are thinking of someone else—perhaps Brian Epstein, the actual "Fifth Beatle" who managed the Fab Four, or maybe you conflated Meek with George Martin (who also wasn't Jewish, but Epstein sure was). Meek actually turned down the Beatles after listening to their demo, deciding they were just another bunch of copycats and that a guy named Rod Argent was a much better bet. Oops.
So where does that leave our tally? Zeroes across the board for heritage and identity, though we have to admit, having a nervous breakdown while convinced the ghost of Buddy Holly is feeding you hit records through a radiator does sound vaguely kabbalistic in the weirdest possible way.
Meek's tragic end—murdering his landlady in a fit of drug-fueled paranoia before turning the shotgun on himself on the anniversary of Buddy Holly's death—certainly doesn't lend itself to traditional kvelling anyway. Brilliant eccentric? Absolutely. Pioneer of indie pop? Without question. Jewish? Not even in an alternate dimension.


