John Cabot
Giovanni Caboto, anglicized as John Cabot because 15th-century Englishmen refused to twist their tongues around vowels, is best known for sailing under the banner of King Henry VII and "discovering" parts of North America that Indigenous peoples had already managed to find thousands of years prior. In 1497, aboard the Matthew, Cabot bumped into Newfoundland, claimed it for England, planted a cross, and laid the groundwork for British dominion over North America.
Naturally, whenever an Italian sailor with murky origins made history around the turn of the 16th century, someone eventually tries to pitch the "secret Jewish roots" theory. It happened with Christopher Columbus, so why not Cabot? Perhaps he was fleeing the Italian Inquisition? Perhaps his family had ties to Sephardic merchants?
Alas, no. Unlike Columbus—whose dubious Sephardic paper trail at least keeps niche historians employed—Cabot has no credible Jewish ancestry whatsoever. He was born in Gaeta or Genoa, became a Venetian citizen, and lived and died as an unremarkable, garden-variety Italian Catholic who just happened to be really good at navigating boats and asking Tudor monarchs for cash.
He set out on a second voyage in 1498 with five ships, disappeared somewhere in the North Atlantic, and was never heard from again. Finding new land for the English crown is an achievement, but doing it without a single drop of Jewish blood means zero kvelling from our department.

