John Cazale
Statistically speaking, John Cazale is the most efficient actor in cinematic history. He appeared in exactly five feature films during his lifetime: The Godfather, The Conversation, The Godfather Part II, Dog Day Afternoon, and The Deer Hunter. Every single one was nominated for the Academy Award for Best Picture, and three of them actually won. That is an absurd, untouchable batting average, made all the more bittersweet by the fact that bone cancer cut his career short at just 42.
Naturally, playing the quintessential tragic weakling Fredo Corleone and Sal the bank robber in Dog Day Afternoon led people to assume Cazale was either straight off the boat from Palermo or deeply entrenched in the outer boroughs. In reality, he was born in Boston to an Italian-American father and an Irish-American mother. Both sides were staunchly, overwhelmingly Catholic.
So no, despite his prominent role alongside Al Pacino (himself raised Catholic) and James Caan (who, let's be fair, spent his entire career successfully fooling people into thinking he was Italian), Cazale possessed not a drop of Jewish heritage. He didn't even have the courtesy to acquire a Jewish spouse, spending his final years in a devoted relationship with a then-up-and-coming actress named Meryl Streep. A legendary talent, but strictly of the Gentile persuasion.




