
Joseph Petrosino
Before there was Eliot Ness, there was Joseph Petrosino. An immigrant from Salerno, Petrosino rose through the ranks of the NYPD when the force was overwhelmingly Irish and not particularly interested in welcoming Italians. Standing just five-foot-three, he compensated for his stature with a fierce intellect, master of disguise tactics, and a deep-seated hatred for the Black Hand—the extortionist precursor to the American Mafia. He arrested thousands, became head of the NYPD's first Italian Squad, and counted Teddy Roosevelt among his biggest admirers.
Naturally, taking down organized crime syndicates is dangerous business, especially when your bosses send you on a secret mission to Sicily while simultaneously leaking your itinerary to the press. In 1909, Petrosino was gunned down in Palermo, becoming the only NYPD officer killed on foreign soil in the line of duty. Nearly 250,000 New Yorkers turned out for his funeral procession, uniting the city's immigrant enclaves in collective mourning.
So, why are we talking about him? Well, Italian and Jewish immigrants shared tenement buildings, pushcart markets, and a collective wariness of the Tammany Hall machine. But Petrosino was as Catholic as an espresso after Sunday Mass. He may have laid the groundwork for future generations of mob-busting detectives, but you won't find a drop of kosher blood in this legendary lawman.

