Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №b4d28d

Julián Carrillo

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
2
K
0 / 15

If twelve notes in an octave were enough for Bach, Beethoven, and the entirety of Western music, Julian Carrillo thought that was terribly small-minded. Born in Ahualulco, Mexico, Carrillo took a violin and a razor blade in 1895, divided the space between notes into sixteenth tones, and decided he had discovered the future. He called it "El Sonido 13" (The Thirteenth Sound), which sounded like an ominous sci-fi film but was actually an elaborate system of microtonality that made listeners feel like their ears were slowly detuning.

Carrillo wasn't just a theorist who annoyed his neighbors; he was an innovator who designed custom pianos, harps, and guitars to play intervals the human ear wasn't entirely sure it wanted to hear. Leopold Stokowski championed his works, he toured Europe and the Americas, and he was even nominated for the Nobel Prize in Physics for his acoustics research. Naturally, the Mexican government treated him like a national monument when it was convenient, and an incomprehensible eccentric when it was not.

So where does that leave his Jewish credentials? Nowhere in the microtonal spectrum, frankly. Carrillo was the nineteenth child of Indigenous and mestizo parents in San Luis Potosi, firmly rooted in Mexican Catholic heritage. No klezmer, no cantorial microtones, no Jewish ancestry tucked between the quarter notes.

Still, we have to respect a man who looked at the standard chromatic scale and said, "Not enough kvetching between the notes." It takes chutzpah to demand sixteenth tones. Just not Jewish chutzpah.

Filed November 4, 2026 · musicians-and-singers

See Also