Mel Sheppard
At the 1908 London Olympics, Melvin Winfield Sheppard was practically unstoppable, capturing gold in the 800 meters, 1500 meters, and the medley relay. Four years later in Stockholm, "Peerless Mel" added another gold in the 4x400 relay and a silver in the 800 for good measure. Before all that glory, the New York City Police Department had rejected him as a recruit because of an allegedly enlarged heart. As Sheppard promptly demonstrated by outrunning the entire planet twice over, his heart worked just fine.
Naturally, whenever an athlete with a slightly ambiguous name like "Sheppard" dominates the early 20th-century track scene, genealogical ears perk up. Did our tribe produce the greatest middle-distance runner of the Edwardian era? Could we claim a man who set world records while wearing leather spikes? It would certainly balance out the centuries of stereotypes about our preferred athletic arena being the chess table.
Alas, no. Sheppard was born into an old-stock, non-Jewish New Jersey family and was decidedly Christian throughout his life. He wasn't Jewish, his heart was fine, and the NYPD looked rather foolish, but we'll have to look elsewhere for our Olympic track kvelling.




