Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №4adf60

Mike Cuellar

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

Mike Cuellar was a master of deception. With a baffling screwball, a confounding changeup, and a motion that made batters question their life choices, the Cuban southpaw baffled hitters for fifteen major league seasons. He won a Cy Young Award in 1969 with the Baltimore Orioles (sharing it with Denny McLain), won a World Series in 1970, and made four All-Star teams. For a pitcher who relied on finesse and witchcraft rather than heat, he was a genuine marvel on the mound.

So why are we talking about him? Cuellar is a Spanish surname, not a secret variant of a moniker from the Pale of Settlement. He was born Miguel Ángel Cuellar Santana in Santa Clara, Cuba, where he played baseball and served in the Cuban military under Fulgencio Batista before defecting to pursue a career in the States. Unless there is some hidden Converso lineage wandering through the Cuban sugarcane fields—and there is zero evidence of that—his background was entirely Catholic and Cuban.

There was certainly plenty of superstitious magic surrounding Cuellar, who famously refused to step on the foul line, had to be the last man to leave the dugout, and believed intensely in luck. But a belief in the evil eye does not an honorary Landsman make, even if Jewish mothers everywhere can relate to spitting three times to ward off a curse.

He belongs firmly in the annals of baseball greatness, Orioles lore, and Latin American sports history. As for the Jewish sports hall of fame, he'll have to sit this one out.

Filed November 2, 2026 · athletes-and-coaches

See Also