Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №3e283c

Milt Campbell

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

In the long, storied history of people confusing African-American athletes with elderly Jewish tailors from Boca Raton, Milton Gray Campbell deserves a prominent chapter. He sounds like a CPA who serves on the temple board, wears beige windbreakers, and complains about the moisture in his pastrami. Instead, Milt was arguably the greatest all-around athlete of the 20th century you've probably forgotten about.

As a high school kid from Plainfield, New Jersey, Campbell took silver in the decathlon at the 1952 Helsinki Olympics, finishing behind Bob Mathias. Four years later in Melbourne, he dominated the field to capture the gold medal, becoming the first Black athlete to win the Olympic decathlon. And just in case conquering ten different track events wasn't enough, Campbell went on to play in the NFL, became a star in the Canadian Football League, and was a nationally ranked judoka. Jim Thorpe gets the press, but Milt had the receipts.

Alas, Campbell’s legendary status yields zero nachas for the Chosen People. Despite a first name that screams Bar Mitzvah gifts and borscht, Milt was raised in a devout Christian family and spent his post-athletic years working as a motivational speaker and youth mentor rooted firmly in his faith.

So no, the decathlon gold remains outside the tribe's trophy case. But if there were an Olympic event for having a name that makes your bubbe do a double-take, Milton would have taken home a second gold.

Filed October 30, 2026 · athletes-and-coaches

See Also