Nancy Walker
If you grew up watching television in the 1970s, Nancy Walker was the undisputed reigning queen of Jewish mothers. As Ida Morgenstern on "The Mary Tyler Moore Show" and "Rhoda", she perfected the meddling, guilt-tripping, brisket-pushing matriarch with such precision that millions assumed she must have spent her childhood in a Lower East Side tenement eating knishes. Add in her decades-long stint as Rosie the Diner Waitress hawking Bounty paper towels, and Walker was an indelible fixture of American pop culture.
Except, as it turns out, Ida Morgenstern was a complete work of fiction in more ways than one. Walker was born Anna Myrtle Swoyer in Philadelphia, the daughter of vaudevillian Dewey Barto (born Stewart Steven Swoyer). Her ancestry was entirely non-Jewish, mostly of German and English extraction. She wasn't an overbearing Jewish mother from the Bronx; she was a tiny, tough-as-nails song-and-dance trouper from an old showbiz family who could sell practically any character handed to her.
She was so naturally funny and sympathetic in the role that Rhoda's creator, James L. Brooks, never thought twice about casting her. Walker went on to direct—most notoriously, the Village People disco musical disaster "Can't Stop the Music"—and worked tirelessly until her death in 1992.
So while Ida Morgenstern may deserve a spot in the Jewish Mother Hall of Fame, the brilliant actress who played her was strictly playing make-believe. A masterclass in acting, perhaps, but zero points on the family tree.
.jpg)



