Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №2fc1c7

Phyllis Smith

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

If you were building a fictional paper-supply company in Scranton, Pennsylvania, you would naturally populate it with eccentric types: an overbearing boss, an autistic beet farmer, a pair of star-crossed lovebirds, and, in sales, a grandmotherly knitter named Phyllis Lapin. With a maiden name like Lapin, a perpetually flustered sweetness, and a knack for dishing out maternal passive-aggression, one could be forgiven for wondering if the actress inhabiting her came straight from a Hadassah meeting.

Alas, Phyllis Smith is not Jewish. Born and raised in St. Louis, Missouri, Smith's path to Scranton did not wind through temple youth groups or summer camp in the Catskills. In fact, before she ever sat behind a Dunder Mifflin desk, she spent her youth as a professional dancer, a burlesque performer, and a cheerleader for the NFL's St. Louis Cardinals, until knee injuries redirected her into Hollywood casting departments.

It was while working as a casting associate for The Office that director Ken Kwapis noticed her soft-spoken delivery while reading lines with auditioning actors and created the role of Phyllis specifically for her. She followed that iconic run by voicing Sadness in Pixar's Inside Out, effectively embodying an emotion that Jews have spent thousands of years perfecting—and yet she achieved it purely on Gentile talent.

So while Bob Vance, Vance Refrigeration, may have landed himself a lovely on-screen bride with an ashkenazi-sounding maiden name, the real Phyllis Smith is entirely free of Jewish roots. She may be adept at guilt and melancholy, but she learned them the hard way: without brisket.

Filed November 11, 2026 · actresses

See Also