Ramón Vinay
If you ask opera aficionados to name the definitive Otello of the mid-20th century, you will inevitably hear the name Ramón Vinay. The Chilean powerhouse possessed a dark, baritonal timbre that made him a legendary heldentenor, thundering through Verdi and Wagner at La Scala, the Met, and Bayreuth with Arturo Toscanini himself nodding in approval. Later in his career, he simply shifted down to singing actual baritone roles because why let a little vocal categorization limit your theatrical conquest?
Given his globe-trotting presence and the perennial operatic game of "spot the hidden tribe member behind the makeup," did Vinay have any Jewish roots? Well, his father was French and his mother was Chilean of Italian descent. He was raised Catholic, sang Catholic, and was laid to rest in his native Chillán without an ounce of Jewish ancestry to claim.
So while opera fans can revel in his recordings of fiery Moorish jealousy and Wagnerian angst, members of the tribe will have to look elsewhere for their cantorial drama. Vinay was magnificent, but Jewish he was not.


