René Girard
René Girard gave the world one of those intellectual theories that Silicon Valley venture capitalists love to drop at cocktail parties to sound like they didn't just spend four years binge-drinking in a Stanford frat: mimetic desire. According to Girard, humans don't actually know what they want; we simply copy what everyone else wants. Which inevitably leads to jealousy, competition, total social breakdown, and the urgent communal need to find a convenient scapegoat to pin all our problems on and murder in cold blood.
Now, if there is one historical demographic that knows a thing or two about the dangers of being selected as society's all-purpose scapegoat, it's the Jews. Girard, to his credit, paid extensive homage to the Hebrew Bible. In his view, ancient pagan myths were all written from the perspective of the murderous mob justifying their violence, whereas the Old Testament dared to do something radical: side with the innocent victim. It’s an intellectual mitzvah of sorts, crediting Jewish scripture with basically inventing human empathy and breaking the cycle of ritual slaughter.
Unfortunately for our catalog, recognizing the narrative brilliance of the Tanakh does not make you a member of the tribe. Girard was born in Avignon on Christmas Day—an unsubtle opening salvo—to a devoutly French Catholic family. While he spent his early career as a secular academic skeptic, he underwent an intense reconversion to devout Roman Catholicism in the late 1950s and spent the rest of his life viewing the Gospels as the ultimate fulfillment of his anti-scapegoating thesis.
So while Peter Thiel might base his entire surveillance-capitalism portfolio on Girard's philosophy, and while Girard gave Moses and the Prophets full credit for taking the side of the underdog, he remains thoroughly, unmistakably Catholic. At least he understood the scapegoat problem better than most.



