Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №4a7ffa

Roy Scheider

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
3
K
0 / 15

With a name like Roy Scheider and a face chiseled out of classic mid-century Brooklyn gravel, you would be forgiven for assuming he had a bar mitzvah and a grandmother who shoved brisket down his throat. Add in the fact that he played a perpetually exasperated, sunburnt police chief on a WASPy New England island, and the cultural radar starts beeping wildly. After all, what could be more Jewish than telling a town council they are making a terrible, fatal mistake, only to be completely ignored until a giant fish eats someone?

Alas, appearances and phonetics can be deceiving. Scheider was the son of Roy Bernhard Scheider, an auto mechanic of Protestant German descent, and Anna Crosson, an Irish Catholic. He was raised Catholic, attended Catholic school in New Jersey, and spent his youth boxing in the Golden Gloves before pivoting to the theater. Zero Jewish heritage on either side of the family tree.

Still, Scheider gave us some of cinema's finest moments, from freezing his tail off in 'The French Connection' to ad-libbing the greatest boat-sizing critique in nautical history in 'Jaws'. He also gave an Oscar-nominated turn as Bob Fosse's neurotic, chain-smoking alter ego in 'All That Jazz'—a performance so steeped in manic showbiz anxiety that it felt honorary. But honorary anxiety doesn't move the needle on the bris meter.

Filed October 23, 2026 · actors

See Also