Sebastián Lelio
When Sebastián Lelio took the Oscar stage in 2018 for 'A Fantastic Woman', handing Chile its first ever Academy Award for Best Foreign Language Film, it seemed like a prime opportunity for tribal head-counting. After all, Latin America has plenty of celebrated Jewish filmmakers, and the name Lelio has a vaguely Mediterranean ring to it. Could he be ours?
Born Sebastián Campos in Mendoza, Argentina, before moving to Chile as a boy, he eventually adopted his maternal grandfather's surname, Lelio. He has directed poignant explorations of outsider lives, from the groundbreaking transgender portrait in 'A Fantastic Woman' to 'Disobedience', a drama set directly inside the insular Orthodox Jewish community of North London. When a director immerses himself so thoroughly in Hendon kosher shops, Shabbat rituals, and rabbinical family dynamics, you can forgive onlookers for assuming he brought some personal baggage to the set.
Alas, no. Lelio's fascination with Orthodox Judaism in 'Disobedience' came strictly from an artist's appreciation of a compelling novel and a tightly bounded subculture, not from a bar mitzvah or a bubbe. He was raised Catholic in Chile, which makes his respectful, nuanced depiction of North London Jewish life all the more impressive—even if it deprives us of an Oscar-winning tribe member.
So while we can appreciate his cinematic empathy and his willingness to treat our rituals with dignity rather than caricature, we cannot count him on the roster. Chile can claim the Oscar; the tribe must look elsewhere.




