Susan Egan
If you were a theater kid in the 1990s, Susan Egan was basically royalty. She originated the role of Belle in the Broadway production of Beauty and the Beast, earning a Tony nomination for wearing an impossibly heavy yellow ballgown eight times a week without collapsing into a pile of tulle. She followed that up by providing the dry, sarcastic purr of Megara in Disney's animated Hercules, singing "I Won't Say (I'm in Love)" and convincing an entire generation of millennials that cynicism was the ultimate romantic trait.
Naturally, in the world of musical theater, having a last name like "Egan" usually means Irish Catholic heritage, and in Susan's case, reality does not disappoint. Born in Seal Beach, California, Egan grew up far from the traditions of the tribe, steeped instead in standard suburban showtunes and general California sunshine.
She has spent decades working alongside practically every Jewish composer, lyricist, and producer on Broadway—from Alan Menken to Stephen Schwartz—and has belted out their tunes with perfection. But singing songs written by Jews in a Disney cartoon scored by a Jewish EGOT winner does not a member of the Tribe make.
Meg may have sworn off falling in love, and we may love Susan Egan's voice, but when it comes to the Jew Score, she's about as gentile as a shamrock.
.jpg)



