Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №24b5c1

Todd Duncan

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
3
K
0 / 15

If you know the sound of Porgy from Gershwin's Porgy and Bess, you know Todd Duncan. George Gershwin famously auditioned over a hundred baritones for the lead role in his masterwork before finding Duncan, a music professor at Howard University. Gershwin heard him sing about twelve measures of an Italian aria before offering him the job on the spot. Duncan later recalled thinking Gershwin was just some Tin Pan Alley hack—until George sat down and played the score, reducing Duncan to tears.

Duncan was a true pioneer in more ways than one. When Porgy and Bess toured to the National Theatre in Washington, D.C. in 1936, Duncan led the cast in a strike, refusing to perform unless the theater allowed desegregated seating for the first time in its history. He went on to become the first African American to sing with a major American opera company when he joined the New York City Opera in 1945, playing Tonio in Pagliacci.

So, where does the Jew-o-Meter fit into the life of this groundbreaking baritone? Well, nowhere genetically or culturally. Duncan was African American, raised in Kentucky and Indiana, and had no Jewish ancestry to speak of. He made his legendary mark singing the melodies of a Brooklyn-born Russian-Jewish immigrant named Jacob Gershwine, which gives him a golden ticket into Jewish cultural trivia, but does not a Jew make.

Filed November 16, 2026 · musicians-and-singers

See Also