Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Jew-ish
Profile №4c4033

Victor de Sabata

Verdict: Jew-ish
I · O · K Score
1
I
3
O
4
K
0 / 15

If you ask opera aficionados to name the greatest recording of Puccini's Tosca, they won't say Karajan or Bernstein. They will inevitably point to the 1953 EMI recording starring Maria Callas, Tito Gobbi, and Giuseppe Di Stefano, commanded by the baton of Victor de Sabata. De Sabata possessed the uncanny ability to pull fiery, razor-sharp precision out of an orchestra without ever losing Italianate passion. Toscanini considered him a peer—a compliment Arturo dispensed approximately three times in his entire eighty-nine years on Earth.

So, where does he fit on our catalog? De Sabata was born in Trieste, then part of Austria-Hungary, to an Italian Catholic father (Amedeo, a chorus master) and a mother, Rosita Tedeschi, who was Jewish. In the convoluted mathematics of halakha, that makes him entirely Jewish. In the eyes of Benito Mussolini's racial laws of 1938, it made him a target. Mussolini's regime eventually forced him to step back from public life because of his Jewish lineage, although his international stature and the devotion of La Scala shielded him from the worst fates until the war ended.

Culturally and religiously, however, de Sabata did not exactly spend his free time studying the Torah. He was baptized, raised Catholic, and spent his life immersed in the profoundly Catholic world of Italian grand opera, punctuated by the occasional Verdi Requiem. His connection to Judaism was largely assigned to him by genealogy and enforced by fascists.

Still, halakhic Jewishness plus one of the finest conductor resumes of the twentieth century counts for something. Even if he spent far more time communing with Scarpia and Desdemona than the God of Abraham, we'll happily take credit for that legendary Tosca.

Filed October 24, 2026 · musicians-and-singers

See Also