Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
Jew
Profile №907309

Waxey Gordon

Verdict: Jew
I · O · K Score
3
I
5
O
1
K
0 / 15

Born Irving Wexler on the Lower East Side of Manhattan, Waxey Gordon did not get his nickname from candle-making. Legend has it he earned the moniker as a teenage pickpocket because his fingers were so smooth they slid out of pockets like wax. Another theory holds that he was simply slick. Regardless, Waxey was not Italian, despite working intimately alongside Lucky Luciano and Frank Costello in the Italian-Jewish bootlegging syndicates of Prohibition.

Waxey was a pure product of the Jewish-American underworld, rising through the ranks of the Lower East Side gangs under "Dopey" Benny Fein before striking gold during Prohibition. He controlled illegal breweries across New Jersey and Pennsylvania, raked in millions, lived at the Upper West Side's Hotel Peter Stuyvesant, and traveled in a customized bulletproof limousine. Naturally, this did not sit well with rivals like Meyer Lansky and Lucky Luciano, who decided the best way to get rid of Waxey wasn't a bullet, but tipping off the IRS. Special prosecutor Thomas Dewey put him away for tax evasion, aided by evidence quietly supplied by Lansky's accountant.

After prison, Waxey tried to reinvent himself, pivoting into wartime black-market sugar during World War II, and later, heroin distribution. This second act proved fatal to his retirement plans; he was busted by the feds in 1951 selling drugs and sent to Alcatraz, where he died of a heart attack a year later.

As a gangster, Waxey lacked the diplomatic savvy of Lansky or the corporate longevity of Costello. As a member of the Tribe, he fits into that colorful, morally bankrupt chapter of 20th-century history where Jewish mothers wept and Jewish sons ran numbers. No kvelling here.

Filed November 4, 2026 · historical-figures

See Also