Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №d711b9

William Forsythe

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
0
K
0 / 15

You might not immediately recognize the name William Forsythe, but you definitely recognize the face. Or rather, you recognize the sneer, the battered mug, and the gravelly baritone that has menaced heroes across American cinema for decades. Whether playing Richie Madano in Steven Seagal's "Out for Justice," gangster Al Capone in "The Untouchables" TV reboot, or a smorgasbord of murderous prison inmates and crooked lawmen, Forsythe built a career out of being the guy who makes you cross the street.

Naturally, playing memorable tough guys often leads into the cinematic realm of organized crime, where Jewish gangsters held serious historical real estate. Forsythe famously played Cockeye in Sergio Leone's Jewish mob opus "Once Upon a Time in America," rubbing shoulders with Robert De Niro and James Woods. He later took on real-life Jewish mobster Meyer Lansky in the gangster film "Mobsters," nailing the calculating calm of Murder, Inc.'s boardroom with chilling perfection.

So, is the actor behind all those gritty mobsters one of the Tribe? Not even close. Forsythe was born in Brooklyn of Italian, Scottish, and Irish descent, and grew up Catholic. He may have worn the fedora and delivered the yiddish-inflected lines of early twentieth-century hoodlums better than most, but that was just good old-fashioned character acting.

While he has certainly contributed his share of memorable villainy to the screen, we can't kvell over a mob boss who only plays Jewish when the cameras start rolling. Keep him on the screen, but leave him off the minyan list.

Filed November 1, 2026 · actors

See Also