Jew / Not Jew
← Archive
NotaJew
Profile №042586

William Frawley

Verdict: Not a Jew
I · O · K Score
0
I
0
O
3
K
0 / 15

Television history is full of iconic duos who secretly hated each other's guts, but few reached the icy, vitriolic perfection of William Frawley and Vivian Vance. As Fred and Ethel Mertz on 'I Love Lucy', they played the bickering landlords whose mutual contempt felt remarkably authentic. That’s because Frawley genuinely could not stand Vance—reportedly furious that she took issue with their twenty-two-year age gap—and Vance was hardly a fan of Frawley's legendary crankiness and penchant for midday cocktails.

Before cementing his legacy as television's archetypal cheapskate landlord (and later as Bub O'Casey on 'My Three Sons'), Frawley was a veteran vaudevillian and prolific Hollywood character actor with over a hundred films under his belt. Born in Burlington, Iowa, to Roman Catholic parents of Irish descent, he grew up singing in church choirs before hitting the road. In other words, there isn't a drop of Jewish heritage lurking behind that famously bald, scowling visage.

Frawley's contract on 'I Love Lucy' famously included a clause allowing him to skip work whenever his beloved New York Yankees played in the World Series, which is certainly a brand of devotion, just not a religious one. He lived as a devout Roman Catholic, died of a heart attack on Hollywood Boulevard in 1966, and was buried at San Fernando Mission Cemetery.

So while Fred Mertz might have pinched pennies tightly enough to trigger the worst stereotypes, William Frawley was Irish-Catholic through and through. Not Jewish at all, but certainly a master of the grumpy kvetch.

Filed October 27, 2026 · actors

See Also