Aaron Peirsol
Aaron. Peirsol. It sounds promising, doesn't it? "Aaron" is about as biblical as you can get without growing sidelocks, and "Peirsol" could easily pass for an Anglicized Ashkenazi surname at a quick glance across an Olympic lane marker. Throw in the fact that he was dominating the pool alongside Jason Lezak and Lenny Krayzelburg during the golden era of American backstroke, and Jewish sports fans were ready to roll out the blue-and-white carpet.
Alas, you can put the bagels away. Peirsol is not Jewish. The name Peirsol (or Piersol/Pearsall) is of English origin, and Aaron hails from standard-issue, sun-bleached Southern California surfing and swimming stock. No bris, no bar mitzvah, no post-race babka. Just pure, unadulterated hydrodynamic mastery powered by non-Jewish genetics.
That doesn't make his athletic resume any less breathtaking. He racked up five Olympic gold medals, two silvers, and obliterated world records in the 100-meter and 200-meter backstroke like he had an outboard motor strapped to his hips. He's one of the greatest backstrokers to ever slice through chlorinated water, which would have made for exquisite kvelling—if only he were actually ours.