Adolph Kiefer
When your first name is Adolph and you happen to win an Olympic gold medal at the 1936 Berlin Games, things are bound to get weird. Adolph Kiefer was just 17 when he crushed the competition in the 100-meter backstroke in Berlin, setting an Olympic record that stood for twenty years. The Fuhrer was so impressed he insisted on shaking the young American's hand, presumably thrilled to celebrate someone named Adolph with sturdy German-immigrant lineage.
Kiefer was not, however, an Aryan propaganda triumph—he was just a kid from Chicago whose parents had emigrated from Germany. The family was German-Catholic and Lutheran, thoroughly devoid of Jewish roots, though Kiefer famously later noted that he had no idea who Hitler really was at the time, only figuring it out when he returned home. During World War II, Kiefer joined the US Navy and completely revolutionized their aquatic survival training, saving thousands of sailors' lives by teaching them how to not drown.
After the war, Kiefer became a swimming mogul. He invented the modern nylon swimsuit, the non-turbulent lane line (which keeps swimmers from being battered by each other's wakes), and introduced the world to the modern backstroke flip turn. A titan of the pool, a lifesaving innovator, and a genuine aquatic legend—just completely and unequivocally not Jewish.