Alta Weiss
Long before "A League of Their Own" made throwing a baseball while wearing a skirt cinematic, Alta Weiss was striking out grown men for cold, hard cash. In 1907, at the tender age of seventeen, the Ohio native signed on as a pitcher for the semi-pro Vermilion Independents. She drew thousands of spectators, threw an unhittable spitball, and eventually barnstormed across the Midwest with her own team, the Weiss All-Stars. Baseball didn't just earn her fame; it paid her way through medical school, making her one of the few female physicians of her era.
Naturally, when sports history fans unearth a forgotten early-20th-century pioneer named "Alta Weiss," the radar goes off. "Alta" sounds an awful lot like a classic Yiddish grandmother, and "Weiss" is about as Ashkenazi as a pastrami on rye. Add in a career path that neatly pivots from athletics to "doctor," and you have what looks like the ultimate piece of early American Jewish sporting trivia.
Except... nope. Not even a little. Alta's grandfather was an immigrant from Germany, and her parents were devout Protestants who raised her in rural Ohio. The name "Weiss" just means "white" in German, and "Alta" was simply a popular Victorian-era girl's name (meaning "high" or "lofty" in Latin), entirely unrelated to the Yiddish nickname given to sickly infants.
So while we'd love to claim the original female doctor-pitcher as a triumph of Jewish athletic prowess, we have to let this one go. Still, if you're looking for a pioneering woman who could baffle men with a curveball and then set their broken bones afterwards, Dr. Weiss remains pretty cool. Just strictly gentile.