Bart Conner
If you were an American watching the 1984 Summer Olympics in Los Angeles, you probably remember Bart Conner. With his boy-next-door grin, impeccably feathered eighties hair, and heroic comeback from a torn bicep, Conner stuck the landing on the parallel bars to take home two gold medals. He became an overnight icon of wholesome, all-American gymnastics excellence, eventually marrying Romanian gymnastics royalty Nadia Comaneci in a televised Bucharest gala that felt like an Olympic coronation.
Naturally, whenever an American gymnast dominates the apparatus with grace, precision, and a name that sounds vaguely short for something Eastern European, wishful members of the tribe start looking for a mezuzah. After all, gymnastics has had its fair share of Jewish stars, from Agnes Keleti to Aly Raisman to Kerri Strug. Could Bart Conner be one of ours?
Alas, no. Conner was born in Chicago, raised in Morton Grove, Illinois, and hails from standard-issue Irish-American roots. There is no hidden bar mitzvah photo, no bubbe secretly slipping him matzah balls before his dismounts. Just a very talented, very goyishe gymnast who could hold an iron cross longer than anyone else in 1984.
So while we would have gladly claimed the man who won America's hearts and married a living legend of Montreal '76, Bart belongs entirely to the gentiles. We'll always have Mitch Gaylord.